20 Years of “Ys”


Every Sunday, milk crate revisits an iconic piece of music history—artist, album, or otherwise—as a part of our weekly crate digging series.

Design by Sophie Parrish

By Lucca Swain

At the beginning of Virginia Woolf’s 1931 novel The Waves, we are painted a picture of a sunrise. But to just call it painterly would be an understatement; as the sun casts its first light over the seashore, we see the world spring to life as if in genesis. Everything is alive, every grain of sand and ray of light a brilliant little miracle given physical form and guided only by the desire to live, to breathe the morning air and experience this miraculous coming forth of all things: 

“Gradually the fibres of the burning bonfire were fused into one haze, one incandescence which lifted the weight of the woollen grey sky on top of it and turned it to a million atoms of soft blue,” writes Woolf, with a sensitivity for even the minutiae of the minutiae. “The surface of the sea slowly became transparent and lay rippling and sparkling until the dark stripes were almost rubbed out.” The world springs forth from a single seed into a million colors, and with it comes an awareness of being, the consciousness snaking forth through the shell of every being bringing with it the shock of a million years of already having been.” 

Woolf then pans over and we see six children playing in the garden. She allows us to know them by way of their internal streams-of-consciousness, and in this way we come to know the children  even more intimately than we would through any kind of external narrator. Throughout The Waves, we watch them change, grow, and awaken to the reality of consciousness through Woolf’s romantic, surrealistic, intensely gorgeous prose-poetry, the actual going-ons of each individual’s lives rendered only in broad strokes. But their feelings–their tragedy, their love, their grief–are made astonishingly vivid, each soliloquy twirling balletically through line after lines of subliminal, impressionistic images, sometimes opaque, sometimes startlingly close to home. For Woolf, the world is a nigh-unknowable series of feelings and sensations, a dazzling, interminable maelstrom of experiences that we can only begin to parse through our relationships with others, and through the moments of resplendent beauty which help to give structure to our lives which, at times, can come to seem all too brief.

It is a frame of mind not dissimilar from that of singer-songwriter Joanna Newsom on her seminal 2006 album Ys, a work which in the twenty years since its release has come to loom so large that it feels at times as if it could be the single most resonant piece of singer-songwriter music released this century. Newsom, in spite of the fact that her catalogue consists of only 4 full-lengths and an EP–and in spite of the fact that her last release was well over a decade ago–has nonetheless established herself as one of the American songwriter canon’s most immutable icons. She is American folk’s most cerebral bard, a songstress whose predilection for byzantine wordplay and labyrinthine compositions only serves to underpin the immense emotional heft lying just below the surface. It is music that is at once intellectual and empathetic, her borderline virtuosic harp playing functioning in tandem with her singularly quirky soprano to  create a sound which exists in a sort of stylistic limbo space: so indebted to the folk traditions of old that it is almost anachronistic, while simultaneously sounding like it could only come from one person during this one specific window in the history of American music.

But that’s all just chatter. Ys is an immense work, so widescale in thematic and emotional breadth that it honestly makes it difficult to write about concisely. That the record is only five tracks but reaches nearly an hour in runtime is already an indicator of what’s to come, though that’s also only foreshadowing the fact that every one of those five tracks—which range in runtime from seven minutes to just under seventeen—are so full to the brim with music that they practically spill over. There are few albums in the folk oeuvre which play with instrumental and lyrical form as fluidly as Ys does—every instrument, every melody, is alive, the compositions so fluid and natural that they seem to create an entire world for themselves even before Newsom’s lyrics come into the picture. The string section is an entity unto itself, moving at times with the quickness of a fox, and other times swaying drunkenly hither and thither before giving way to Newsom’s glittering, polyphonic harp. 

Newsom herself is no slouch in that regard either; she is as much a part of the one organism as the instruments, darting through the tangle of vines and forest cover like a hawk hunting prey. “Everything sloped like it was dragged from a rope / In the mouth of the south below,” she sings, as the strings gradually slant downwards; her voice arcs up, and the orchestra moves in for the kill in tandem. 

Herculean opening track “Emily” is about as effective a scene setter as you could ask for, a song whose emotionally turbulent narrative of filial alienation is matched beat-for-beat by the unfettered, unpredictable nature of its arrangement, and the undeniably potent melancholy of Newsom’s voice. “Come on home; the poppies are all grown knee-deep by now,” she sings mournfully, a plea for reconciliation addressed to a sister either real or imagined. The harp and the music interlock symbiotically, at times swelling dynamically almost to the point of bursting, at other times coasting as if a ship and the wind in its sails. “And Emily, I saw you last night by the river / I dreamed you were skipping little stones across the stones across the surface of the water / Frowning at the angle where they were lost, and slipped under forever,” Newsom lets loose, the arrangement briefly regressing, before breaching the surface with such understated emotional intensity that it practically shakes the world around it. 

And yet, perhaps the greatest asset which Ys has at its disposal is Joanna Newsom’s intense fascination with what seems like everything there is and has ever been. Like Virginia Woolf, Newsom has a major sensitivity for things small and large: moths, grief, dying brown birds, the quality of a summer evening’s light—nothing is immune. And like Woolf, it’s all made to feel fleeting and momentous in equal measure. It is all alive, or possesses within itself the potential and desire to be alive. And within the world of Ys, any such desire can be granted with merely the click of a pen.

Each of Ys’ five pieces spawned from a particularly tumultuous year occurred in Newsom’s life, a personal tragedy or going-on which acts as the baseline of each suite. But in listening to Newsom’s album, the first impression any astute listener will gain is that while any one song could reasonably, if not a little haphazardly, be boiled down to one thematic topic or idea, the power of Ys ultimately stems from the fact that the songs actually feel massive. There are worlds within worlds contained within singular passages and stanzas here, dense tapestries of feeling woven so tightly into the fabric of Newsom’s literary zeal that they at first appear totally inscrutable. Every line only adds onto the picture, each word in possession of a raw kinetic energy that allows it to flourish even within the mind-boggingly intricate canvas which Newsom sketches out. The seventeen-minute centerpiece “Only Skin” would be the first to point the finger at in this regard, the part of the album where it feels as if the entire thing is finally coalescing into one coherent narrative (which may have been Newsom’s intention). But take one look into the actual meat-and-potatoes of the track, and it immediately seems as though you’re staring out into the open ocean, the vastness of it all so great as to almost induce a state of sublimity. Newsom transmutes the benign into the existential and then back again, at one point warbling out, “While down in the lowlands, the crops are all coming / We have everything,” before immediately taking us up into the stratosphere: “Life is fumbling blissful towards death.” All beautiful things exist concurrently with the possibility of nonexistence, whether it be birds, spiders, relationships, or even the concept of love itself. It’s all there, jam packed into “Only Skin.” 

But the music is hardly inaccessible; if anything, whatever initial feelings allowed for the conceptualization of the songs on Ys are only exponentially magnified by the music’s structure, even as the words separate fractally further and further from the original subject matter. One of the great pleasures of Ys is its almost unbelievable ability to always have another card hidden up its sleeve, so that whether you are a new listener or an experienced veteran, there will always be another line or melodic passage which has the potential to jump out and pierce you directly through the heart when you least expect it.

On “Sawdust & Diamonds,” the only solo-harp song on the entire record, Newsom maintains an esoteric veneer for much of the near-ten-minute runtime, jumping from descriptions of unnaturally long ears full of bees to makeshift doves crafted from sawdust to a shockingly affecting meditation on death predicated upon a series of “long face” witticisms. On first listen, it all comes off as absolutely cryptic and impenetrable, vague notions of mortality and heartbreak abounding but never congealing into one image, but that’s just before Newsom snakes out one heartbreaking series of lines towards the track’s end: “And though my wrists and waist seemed so easy to break / Still, my dear, I’d have walked you to the edge of the water / And they will recognize all the lines of your face / In the face of the daughter of the daughter of my daughter,” she sings. The image comes into focus – the entire song is recontextualized. Suddenly, mortality is no longer a vague notion, but a present reality.  With the snap of a finger, the music moves from an intellectual to an entirely emotional affair, larger than life and more personal than death. Newsom’s fascination with water as the wellspring of all life, as well as the ultimate harbinger of destruction, is a constant throughout the whole of Ys, but it never gets more visceral than it does here. As Sufjan Stevens once so wisely put it: “We’re all gonna die.” 

With every listen, the songs of Ys reveal their weight, line after line after line an indispensable treasure trove of thoughts and feelings and associations which function ingeniously on their own as well as within the whole. Newsom’s vocal performance is indispensable in that regard, her squeaky treble carrying with it a deceptive capability for emotional destruction as well as catharsis. That she manages to sell every single one of Ys’ 3681 words without faltering is only a testament to her sheer conviction to the craft and to her beliefs as an artist. 

Ys is a record of epic beauty, one which opts to illustrate the entire world as a constantly moving series of parts, each with their own internal logic and reason for being. Everything is deserving of the empathy which personification brings, even those things which we would otherwise consider unthinking or unfeeling. The waves on the beach “paw like dogs;” the meteorites in the sky are long-faded, smoldering love letters; eyelashes shake like “wind on rushes.” Newsom finds in the natural world a mirror where others would find an escape, a reflection of the self which sees all the splendor of being alive as inseparable from the lingering terror of death and grief. 

For Newsom, man’s experience of consciousness and the natural world is a constant overlapping series of points. And much like Virginia Woolf, Newsom understands that all things must return to that world in the end, one way or another. But even twenty years on, the way in which Newsom renders plainly the confusion of our existence continues to be so singular and so cathartic that it still feels like it could have been released tomorrow, and it would still be as earth-shattering as it was in 2006. On every relisten of Ys, it only becomes more apparent that the album has a nigh-unlimited amount to say about the current condition of being, always a new lyric or instrumental flourish or moment of vocal ecstasy to get lost in. The world is, and it will continue to be, now and forever. “Scrape your knee, it is only skin…”